Unpopular opinions you genuinely hold

[Gavin Chipper]

People walking their dogs should have poo bags on them anyway and are part of the wider dog walking community, so if they see some dog poo that didn't come from their own dog, they should pick it up anyway and not be all "Well it's nothing to do with me" about it. Especially on that bridge on my run route that always has fucking dog shit on it.

Well you could carry poo bags and pick the shit up too

I'm not stopping on a run. Plus these people are all well versed in the procedure, and most of them have probably missed their own dog's poo at some point so should be paying something back to the community. And generally everyone else has to put up with other people's out-of-control dogs running up to them and jumping on them and have to pretend it's not a problem and actually quite enjoyable. So this is for the general antisocial nature of their dog-related activities.

[Marc Meakin]

It would be nice if the wider McDonalds-eating community acted in similar fashion.

I guess a discarded burger could be mistaken for a dog poo

[Marc Meakin]

People walking their dogs should have poo bags on them anyway and are part of the wider dog walking community, so if they see some dog poo that didn't come from their own dog, they should pick it up anyway and not be all "Well it's nothing to do with me" about it. Especially on that bridge on my run route that always has fucking dog shit on it.

Well you could carry poo bags and pick the shit up too

I'm not stopping on a run. Plus these people are all well versed in the procedure, and most of them have probably missed their own dog's poo at some point so should be paying something back to the community. And generally everyone else has to put up with other people's out-of-control dogs running up to them and jumping on them and have to pretend it's not a problem and actually quite enjoyable. So this is for the general antisocial nature of their dog-related activities.

Or put extra large poo bags over your footwear so it doesn't matter if you tread in dog shit.
Btw who picks up foxes shit?

[Mark James]

The Marchioness of Cholmondeley is better looking than Kate Middleton.

[Gavin Chipper]

Punch a woman when she's down.

[Mark James]

Oh shit. I completely forgot I was told about Kate's diagnosis last night.

[Marc Meakin]

The Marchioness of Cholmondeley is better looking than Kate Middleton.

Rose Hanbury.
Is she the one that Prince William was knobbing.
Yes I shouldn't kick a man when he is down, (wife and dad with cancer an estranged from his brother)

[Ian Volante]

The Marchioness of Cholmondeley is better looking than Kate Middleton.

I like my women with more chin.

[Marc Meakin]

The Marchioness of Cholmondeley is better looking than Kate Middleton.

I like my women with more chin.

And less consonants

[Marc Meakin]

It's time to stop making Sundays special in retail especially.
Most workers are on single time anyway so why restrict trade to 6 hours
As for Easter Sunday meaning most shops are shut, because it's not a bank hokiday you are still expected to work.
Surely practising Christians are in the minority in the UK

[Marc Meakin]

Big wedding ceremonies are a waste of money,
You spend thousands and relatives you don't see from one year to the next all expect invites a fortune on a dress /suite,.
Better to just get married with a couple f witnesses and take your family out for a meal at a later date

Which is what I'm going to do next Wednesday.(3rd April)
I know some of my family will be pissed off but hey ho

[Fiona T]

Big wedding ceremonies are a waste of money,
You spend thousands and relatives you don't see from one year to the next all expect invites a fortune on a dress /suite,.
Better to just get married with a couple f witnesses and take your family out for a meal at a later date

Which is what I'm going to do next Wednesday.(3rd April)
I know some of my family will be pissed off but hey ho

Congratulations!

[Elliott Mellor]

Big wedding ceremonies are a waste of money,
You spend thousands and relatives you don't see from one year to the next all expect invites a fortune on a dress /suite,.
Better to just get married with a couple f witnesses and take your family out for a meal at a later date

Which is what I'm going to do next Wednesday.(3rd April)
I know some of my family will be pissed off but hey ho

You mean someone actually agreed to marry you?

[Marc Meakin]

Big wedding ceremonies are a waste of money,
You spend thousands and relatives you don't see from one year to the next all expect invites a fortune on a dress /suite,.
Better to just get married with a couple f witnesses and take your family out for a meal at a later date

Which is what I'm going to do next Wednesday.(3rd April)
I know some of my family will be pissed off but hey ho

You mean someone actually agreed to marry you?

That makes 2 people
Probably because my first wedding was an expensive disaster (2 cakes, in law doing a runner from paying for the meal) and my intended being very shy plus my in laws being poorly a hastily arranged quiet wedding seemed best.
If i live another 43 years my anniversary will be Easter Sunday

[Gavin Chipper]

Big wedding ceremonies are a waste of money,
You spend thousands and relatives you don't see from one year to the next all expect invites a fortune on a dress /suite,.
Better to just get married with a couple f witnesses and take your family out for a meal at a later date

Which is what I'm going to do next Wednesday.(3rd April)
I know some of my family will be pissed off but hey ho

Is this why I'm not invited?

[Marc Meakin]

Relating to my politics thread post I think if a leader of the elected government leaves or dies in office it should be in the constitution that a general election should be triggered within 6 months

[Gavin Chipper]

Relating to my politics thread post I think if a leader of the elected government leaves or dies in office it should be in the constitution that a general election should be triggered within 6 months

I disagree with that. We elect individual members of parliament, and the government simply forms from that. It's seems crazy to be that all those 650 people that have been elected by the people ostensibly for five years only have their positions dependent on this one person.

Although in practice a lot of people do vote based on the leader of the party they are voting for (see Boris Johnson), it shouldn't be encouraged and certainly shouldn't be encoded into law.

[Marc Meakin]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

[Tal Lessner]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

I saw many 60s-80s artists in the past 20 years, most of them were still great performers and no tribute band, as good as it is, can get even close.

[Fiona T]

I was lucky enough to see Madness a few years ago - still brilliant and full of energy, if a little chubbier than they were back in the day!

[Gavin Chipper]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

Better in what way though? If it's just about sound quality you might as well just listen to a recording and not see anyone live.

[Marc Meakin]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

Better in what way though? If it's just about sound quality you might as well just listen to a recording and not see anyone live.

I meant if you want see a live band then a tribute version of Duran Duran would have a more competent singer than Simon Le Bon.
There are exceptions of course, Mick Jagger can still sing but Elton John, Rod Stewart nah

[Ian Volante]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

Better in what way though? If it's just about sound quality you might as well just listen to a recording and not see anyone live.

I meant if you want see a live band then a tribute version of Duran Duran would have a more competent singer than Simon Le Bon.

You could have said that in 1982 too though.

[Marc Meakin]

Better in what way though? If it's just about sound quality you might as well just listen to a recording and not see anyone live.

I meant if you want see a live band then a tribute version of Duran Duran would have a more competent singer than Simon Le Bon.

You could have said that in 1982 too though.

Valid point, he was certainly shit at Live Aid

[Paul Worsley]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

I would rather see the original band and I used to be a bit dismissive of tribute bands, but then my daughter joined Rumours of Fleetwood Mac in the Christine McVie role, so i re-evaluated.

Good tribute bands can be very good indeed. The problem is that they're not really a band, but more of a show. The people that pay to watch expect them to sound as much like the original band as possible.

[Marc Meakin]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

I would rather see the original band and I used to be a bit dismissive of tribute bands, but then my daughter joined Rumours of Fleetwood Mac in the Christine McVie role, so i re-evaluated.

Good tribute bands can be very good indeed. The problem is that they're not really a band, but more of a show. The people that pay to watch expect them to sound as much like the original band as possible.

One would assume it's reflected in the entrance fee.
The cost of Elton John's last concerts were ridiculous

[Paul Worsley]

Good tribute bands are better to see live than the original band if that band was from the 70s or early 80s

I would rather see the original band and I used to be a bit dismissive of tribute bands, but then my daughter joined Rumours of Fleetwood Mac in the Christine McVie role, so i re-evaluated.

Good tribute bands can be very good indeed. The problem is that they're not really a band, but more of a show. The people that pay to watch expect them to sound as much like the original band as possible.

One would assume it's reflected in the entrance fee.
The cost of Elton John's last concerts were ridiculous

Australian Pink Floyd tickets are all over £100 now. I saw Pink Floyd perform The Wall in 1980 at Earl's Court for £14 (£75 adjusted for inflation)

[Marc Meakin]

Australian Pink Floyd are probably better than the original Members now.

That is what I call an unpopular opinion

[Tal Lessner]

Australian Pink Floyd are probably better than the original Members now.

That is what I call an unpopular opinion

Probably true, since without Syd Barrett they were boring as fuck.

[Matt Rutherford]

It's time to stop making Sundays special in retail especially.
Most workers are on single time anyway so why restrict trade to 6 hours
As for Easter Sunday meaning most shops are shut, because it's not a bank hokiday you are still expected to work.
Surely practising Christians are in the minority in the UK

There are more Christians than you might think. In addition, keeping at least one day restricted is something to at least prevent overwork. You let companies go lassiez-faire, they'll take it. Weekends are valuable to a lot of people. If the law protects that in some ways (i.e Sundays) then that is something to be celebrated

[David Williams]

Relating to my politics thread post I think if a leader of the elected government leaves or dies in office it should be in the constitution that a general election should be triggered within 6 months

I disagree with that. We elect individual members of parliament, and the government simply forms from that. It's seems crazy to be that all those 650 people that have been elected by the people ostensibly for five years only have their positions dependent on this one person.

Although in practice a lot of people do vote based on the leader of the party they are voting for (see Boris Johnson), it shouldn't be encouraged and certainly shouldn't be encoded into law.

And if that was the rule Johnson would still be PM.

[Marc Meakin]

Nah we would have got a new government, though maybe 6 months of Truss fucking up the country rather than 6 weeks (was it even that long)

[David Williams]

Nah we would have got a new government, though maybe 6 months of Truss fucking up the country rather than 6 weeks (was it even that long)

My point is that if replacing a leader means a general election, and a leader can only be removed by his party's MPs voting him out - they aren't very likely to vote him out.

[Marc Meakin]

Extra time in football is a waste of time.
Why not have penalties at 90 minutes and have 10 penalty takers (not all keepers areas good as Ederson)
This will stop teams from conserving energy at around 85 minutes and go for it more.
Having 10 penalties each means it's more of a leveller
Also teams that have players sent off will have a disadvantage come penalties and more likely their GK will have to take one

[Mark James]

I kinda like this idea. Wouldn't mind scrapping extra time and sure, have 11 penalties each. Everyone should have to take one and save one.

[Gavin Chipper]

I was talking to a friend about penalty shoot-outs the other day (he doesn't like them) and we were talking about alternatives. I've heard people suggesting reducing the number of players on the pitch before. I also suggested (probably not originally) getting rid of goalkeepers during extra time. You still keep 11 players and one geezer can obviously stand in goal if he wants but he doesn't have the special handball powers.

[Marc Meakin]

I was talking to a friend about penalty shoot-outs the other day (he doesn't like them) and we were talking about alternatives. I've heard people suggesting reducing the number of players on the pitch before. I also suggested (probably not originally) getting rid of goalkeepers during extra time. You still keep 11 players and one geezer can obviously stand in goal if he wants but he doesn't have the special handball powers.

Well in the Lille v Aston Villa game the referee seemed to send off the Villa goalkeeper during the penalty shoot out but alas he changed his mind.
I can only assume an outfield player would have had to go in goal

[Ben Wilson]

Taylor Swift is okay. Her music is good, but not great, and as a performer she's a solid 7.5/10 but nowhere near the generational talent her fans make her out to be and not even remotely the 'death of music' some of her haters seem to think she is.

[Jon O'Neill]

Taylor Swift is okay. Her music is good, but not great, and as a performer she's a solid 7.5/10 but nowhere near the generational talent her fans make her out to be and not even remotely the 'death of music' some of her haters seem to think she is.

The silent majority agree with you on this, I'm pretty sure. Although 7.5 is a bit high.

[Marc Meakin]

Taylor Swift is okay. Her music is good, but not great, and as a performer she's a solid 7.5/10 but nowhere near the generational talent her fans make her out to be and not even remotely the 'death of music' some of her haters seem to think she is.

The silent majority agree with you on this, I'm pretty sure. Although 7.5 is a bit high.

So many artists first record turns out to be one of their best.
Love Sory by Taylor Swift
Genie in a Bottle by Christine Aguilera
Even Holiday by Madonna

[Matt Rutherford]

I was talking to a friend about penalty shoot-outs the other day (he doesn't like them) and we were talking about alternatives. I've heard people suggesting reducing the number of players on the pitch before. I also suggested (probably not originally) getting rid of goalkeepers during extra time. You still keep 11 players and one geezer can obviously stand in goal if he wants but he doesn't have the special handball powers.

Well in the Lille v Aston Villa game the referee seemed to send off the Villa goalkeeper during the penalty shoot out but alas he changed his mind.
I can only assume an outfield player would have had to go in goal

Pedantry ensues Martinez was booked during the main game-that card wasn't carried forward to the penalty shootout (nature of rules I don't know, but that's what happened). I'm not complaining-though I did virtually void my bowels when I saw the ref reach for his pocket.

It also confirmed that Emi Martinez is well and truly the Adam Latchford of English Football.

[Gavin Chipper]

Taylor Swift is okay. Her music is good, but not great, and as a performer she's a solid 7.5/10 but nowhere near the generational talent her fans make her out to be and not even remotely the 'death of music' some of her haters seem to think she is.

The silent majority agree with you on this, I'm pretty sure. Although 7.5 is a bit high.

I didn't realise she was supposed to be a "Marmite" figure.

In other news, I quite like Marmite.

By the way, in this interview, Neil Tennant hits on something I've often thought:

“I'd be very interested, if I'm still alive, to see how Taylor Swift is regarded in years to come,” says Tennant, “because she has this massive success - but normally with people with massive success, there's a popular legacy of songs that everyone knows.

“If you're Michael Jackson, who doesn’t know Billie Jean or Beat It? With Taylor Swift I never feel it's the moment where your grandmother knows her song.”