How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Obviously based on Peter's thread about numbers... 11,900,000odd numbers games is a lot. How many letters games are there? More? Or less?
What's your hunch? My guess is less. Or actually maybe more, thinking about all the duplicated letters in the piles.
And who's going to work it out...? (state your letter distribution when doing so please!)
What's your hunch? My guess is less. Or actually maybe more, thinking about all the duplicated letters in the piles.
And who's going to work it out...? (state your letter distribution when doing so please!)

 Acolyte
 Posts: 171
 Joined: Fri Nov 07, 2008 9:42 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Can't be bothered to do a proper calculation, but randomly picking 9 letters and dividing by 9! to remove duplicate selections (ignoring duplicate letters within selections) gives just over 15,000,000. Refining this to pick valid numbers of consonants and vowels brings it down to around 3,500,000.
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
That doesn't seem right, are you sure? Dividing by 9! seems wrong (there's only one AAAAAAAAA but you're saying there's 9! of them, aren't you?) If I have an alphabet of 3 letters, and I'm choosing a selection of 3 letters, the possibles are AAA,AAB,AAC,ABB,ABC,ACC,BBB,BBC,BCC,CCC. 10 selections. Your calculation would give (3^3)/3! = 4.5Thomas Cappleman wrote:Can't be bothered to do a proper calculation, but randomly picking 9 letters and dividing by 9! to remove duplicate selections (ignoring duplicate letters within selections) gives just over 15,000,000. Refining this to pick valid numbers of consonants and vowels brings it down to around 3,500,000.

 Acolyte
 Posts: 171
 Joined: Fri Nov 07, 2008 9:42 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Yeah, I was deliberately ignoring that for simplicity. I suspect that this error will be greater than the fact that I'm duplicating some consonants illegally for my second estimate, so looking probably around 56 million.Jon Corby wrote:That doesn't seem right, are you sure? Dividing by 9! seems wrong (there's only one AAAAAAAAA but you're saying there's 9! of them, aren't you?) If I have an alphabet of 3 letters, and I'm choosing a selection of 3 letters, the possibles are AAA,AAB,AAC,ABB,ABC,ACC,BBB,BBC,BCC,CCC. 10 selections. Your calculation would give (3^3)/3! = 4.5Thomas Cappleman wrote:Can't be bothered to do a proper calculation, but randomly picking 9 letters and dividing by 9! to remove duplicate selections (ignoring duplicate letters within selections) gives just over 15,000,000. Refining this to pick valid numbers of consonants and vowels brings it down to around 3,500,000.
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Your answer seems hideously inaccurate. You're assuming that there are 9! repetitions for each selection, but that only applies when all the letters are different. Even with a selection of 3 letters from an alphabet of 3 your calculation gives only 45% of the true answer! With bigger figures that will surely be amplified! I think you've massively understated the answer.

 Newbie
 Posts: 26
 Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2011 1:42 pm
 Location: Dunstable, Bedfordshire
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
The formula for finding the number of combinations of r letters chosen from n different kinds of letter is (n+r1)! / r!(n1)! (where repetition is allowed and the order doesn't matter)
The number of ways of dealing 3 vowels from 5 different kinds of vowels is 7!/(3!*4!) = 35
dealing 4 vowels = 70
dealing 5 vowels = 126
The number of ways of dealing 4 consonants from 21 different kinds of consonants is 24!/(4!*20!) = 10626
dealing 5 consonants = 53130
dealing 6 consonants = 230230
So pairing these up for the three different kinds of letters rounds:
Number of possible 4C 5V letters rounds= 10626*126 = 1,338,876
Number of possible 5C 4V letters rounds= 53130*70 = 3,719,100
Number of possible 6C 3V letters rounds= 230230*35 = 8,058,050
Adding these up gives 13,116,026. I think.
The number of ways of dealing 3 vowels from 5 different kinds of vowels is 7!/(3!*4!) = 35
dealing 4 vowels = 70
dealing 5 vowels = 126
The number of ways of dealing 4 consonants from 21 different kinds of consonants is 24!/(4!*20!) = 10626
dealing 5 consonants = 53130
dealing 6 consonants = 230230
So pairing these up for the three different kinds of letters rounds:
Number of possible 4C 5V letters rounds= 10626*126 = 1,338,876
Number of possible 5C 4V letters rounds= 53130*70 = 3,719,100
Number of possible 6C 3V letters rounds= 230230*35 = 8,058,050
Adding these up gives 13,116,026. I think.
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
A bit of reading around leads me to learning about binomial(n+k1,k) of choosing (with replacement) k objects from n.
So 3 vowels is binomial(7,3) * binomial(26,6) = 8058050
4 vowels is binomial(8,4) * binomial(25,5) = 3719100
5 vowels is binomial(9,5) * binomial(24,4) = 1338876
which added together gives us 13,116,026.
So that's what it would be if there were at least 6 of every consonant and at least 5 of every vowel in their respective piles (i.e. that count includes stuff like UUUZZZZZZ, which can't happen.)
I'm not sure now how to count those though, and remove them.
And I'm still unclear as to whether we will end up with MORE or FEWER possible letters games than numbers games. Isn't this exciting?
Edit: Ha, brilliant Robert. Nice to have that confirmed anyway! Any ideas on how we deal with the actual distribution (if we can find it), and do you have a hunch for the difference it will make to the figure?
So 3 vowels is binomial(7,3) * binomial(26,6) = 8058050
4 vowels is binomial(8,4) * binomial(25,5) = 3719100
5 vowels is binomial(9,5) * binomial(24,4) = 1338876
which added together gives us 13,116,026.
So that's what it would be if there were at least 6 of every consonant and at least 5 of every vowel in their respective piles (i.e. that count includes stuff like UUUZZZZZZ, which can't happen.)
I'm not sure now how to count those though, and remove them.
And I'm still unclear as to whether we will end up with MORE or FEWER possible letters games than numbers games. Isn't this exciting?
Edit: Ha, brilliant Robert. Nice to have that confirmed anyway! Any ideas on how we deal with the actual distribution (if we can find it), and do you have a hunch for the difference it will make to the figure?
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
The other thing of course is that even with the correct distribution of letters, I believe in reality it's still not a completely random selection because somebody sifts through to make sure there aren't too many of the same letter in a row and that sort of thing. But we should ignore that for this exercise.
 JimBentley
 Legend
 Posts: 2659
 Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 6:39 pm
 Location: Redcar, UK
 Contact:
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Is this open to pure guesswork? If it is, my guess is 6,031,769.
exciting music http://fahnn.co.uk/ other stuff http://toolongdintread.blogspot.co.uk/ correct opinions https://twitter.com/fahnn
 Thomas Carey
 Devotee
 Posts: 957
 Joined: Sun Jan 09, 2011 4:17 pm
 Location: NorthWest of Bradford
 Contact:
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
http://www.c4countdown.co.uk/viewtopic. ... 82#p140469 is probably our best shot at a decent consonant distribution.
That's 1 JKQXYZ, 2 BFHVW, 3 C, 4 GMP, 5 L and 6+ DNRST.
As for vowels, it doesn't matter as there's going to be at least 5 of each, so Rob's numbers are fine.
That's 1 JKQXYZ, 2 BFHVW, 3 C, 4 GMP, 5 L and 6+ DNRST.
As for vowels, it doesn't matter as there's going to be at least 5 of each, so Rob's numbers are fine.
signature
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Cool, cheers. Erm... now how do we absorb this information into the calculations?Thomas Carey wrote:http://www.c4countdown.co.uk/viewtopic. ... 82#p140469 is probably our best shot at a decent consonant distribution.
That's 1 JKQXYZ, 2 BFHVW, 3 C, 4 GMP, 5 L and 6+ DNRST.
As for vowels, it doesn't matter as there's going to be at least 5 of each, so Rob's numbers are fine.

 Postapocalypse
 Posts: 8332
 Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:37 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Hmm. I'm saying 6,031,770.JimBentley wrote:Is this open to pure guesswork? If it is, my guess is 6,031,769.

 Acolyte
 Posts: 171
 Joined: Fri Nov 07, 2008 9:42 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Used this to work out how to determine the number of possible consonant combinations: http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/56197.html. It turns out the way to choose n consonants is to take the coefficient of x^n in the expansion of (1+x)^6*(1+x+x^2)^5*(1+x+x^2+x^3)*(1+x+x^2+x^3+x^4)^3*(1+x+x^2+x^3+x^4+x^5)*(1+x+x^2+x^3+x^4+x^5+x^6)^5. The first term is because there are 6 letters with 1 tile, the second is 5 letters with 2 tiles, etc. This gives 9149 ways of getting 4 tiles, 41670 for 5, and 161415 for 6. Combining with the ways of choosing vowels gives a final answer of 9,719,199.
 Graeme Cole
 Series 65 Champion
 Posts: 1511
 Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 9:59 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
I just wrote a program to work it out a different way (nothing to do with coefficients of polynomials) and got the same answer.Thomas Cappleman wrote:Used this to work out how to determine the number of possible consonant combinations: http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/56197.html. It turns out the way to choose n consonants is to take the coefficient of x^n in the expansion of (1+x)^6*(1+x+x^2)^5*(1+x+x^2+x^3)*(1+x+x^2+x^3+x^4)^3*(1+x+x^2+x^3+x^4+x^5)*(1+x+x^2+x^3+x^4+x^5+x^6)^5. The first term is because there are 6 letters with 1 tile, the second is 5 letters with 2 tiles, etc. This gives 9149 ways of getting 4 tiles, 41670 for 5, and 161415 for 6. Combining with the ways of choosing vowels gives a final answer of 9,719,199.
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Great stuff guys (he says, abandoning the bruteforcer he was in the middle of writing).
So there are fewer letters games than numbers games. WHAT A DAY THIS HAS BEEN.
So there are fewer letters games than numbers games. WHAT A DAY THIS HAS BEEN.

 Postapocalypse
 Posts: 8332
 Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:37 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
I love how this forum generally has taken off recently.
 Johnny Canuck
 Kiloposter
 Posts: 1134
 Joined: Sun Oct 03, 2010 10:44 pm
 Location: Atlantic Canada
 Contact:
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
So based on this, and using an estimate of the number of valid conundrumable words (probably 10,000 or so), we should be able to work out how many different possible shows there can be.
* Despite everything, it's still you.

 Acolyte
 Posts: 171
 Joined: Fri Nov 07, 2008 9:42 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
That will get more complicated again, as each letters round will remove a load of other possibilities for the later rounds (as the letters tiles get used up).Johnny Canuck wrote:So based on this, and using an estimate of the number of valid conundrumable words (probably 10,000 or so), we should be able to work out how many different possible shows there can be.

 Postapocalypse
 Posts: 8332
 Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:37 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
How many possible contestants are there?
 Graeme Cole
 Series 65 Champion
 Posts: 1511
 Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 9:59 pm
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
The population of the world is 7 billion, so 6,999,999,999 unless you somehow persuade Matt Bayfield to apply.Gavin Chipper wrote:How many possible contestants are there?
 Johnny Canuck
 Kiloposter
 Posts: 1134
 Joined: Sun Oct 03, 2010 10:44 pm
 Location: Atlantic Canada
 Contact:
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
6,999,999,998 until I graduate. Unless I flunk out. Then we're back up to 6,999,999,999.Graeme Cole wrote:The population of the world is 7 billion, so 6,999,999,999 unless you somehow persuade Matt Bayfield to apply.Gavin Chipper wrote:How many possible contestants are there?
* Despite everything, it's still you.
 JimBentley
 Legend
 Posts: 2659
 Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 6:39 pm
 Location: Redcar, UK
 Contact:
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Can we have 'likes' back etc.? Seriously Matt though, apply now.Graeme Cole wrote:The population of the world is 7 billion, so 6,999,999,999 unless you somehow persuade Matt Bayfield to apply.Gavin Chipper wrote:How many possible contestants are there?
exciting music http://fahnn.co.uk/ other stuff http://toolongdintread.blogspot.co.uk/ correct opinions https://twitter.com/fahnn
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Graeme Cole wrote:The population of the world is 7 billion, so 6,999,999,999 unless you somehow persuade Matt Bayfield to apply.Gavin Chipper wrote:How many possible contestants are there?
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Well done Gev, you were closer.Gavin Chipper wrote:Hmm. I'm saying 6,031,770.JimBentley wrote:Is this open to pure guesswork? If it is, my guess is 6,031,769.
 JimBentley
 Legend
 Posts: 2659
 Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 6:39 pm
 Location: Redcar, UK
 Contact:
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Yeah, but he won't get anywhere on Manic Miner with his guess.Jon Corby wrote:Well done Gev, you were closer.Gavin Chipper wrote:Hmm. I'm saying 6,031,770.JimBentley wrote:Is this open to pure guesswork? If it is, my guess is 6,031,769.
exciting music http://fahnn.co.uk/ other stuff http://toolongdintread.blogspot.co.uk/ correct opinions https://twitter.com/fahnn

 Devotee
 Posts: 532
 Joined: Thu May 14, 2009 8:39 am
 Location: Seated at a computer
Re: How many Letters puzzles are there in total?
Kind of you to suggest it, Jim, but Graeme's right. I'm sure the last sort of applicant the Countdown team want is yet another universityeducated white male exScrabbler, especially one who has also played extensively on apterous.JimBentley wrote:Can we have 'likes' back etc.? Seriously Matt though, apply now.Graeme Cole wrote:The population of the world is 7 billion, so 6,999,999,999 unless you somehow persuade Matt Bayfield to apply.Gavin Chipper wrote:How many possible contestants are there?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Philip Wilson and 2 guests