c4countdown

Elliott Mellor

What arguments is he giving for them being fake, exactly?

Elliott Mellor

Happy to also get a max game here. Felt really bad for Susan - she seemed very strong on the letters and if her numbers had been up to scratch she could have had 11 or 12 maxes. One of the more capable contestants of late and I was rooting for her to win.

Elliott Mellor

Countdown Team wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 24, 2018 8:16 pm
We tell Rachel if the game is impossible.

……

Edit to add......
How do we know it's impossible? We text Elliott Mellor.

Only just seen this

Elliott Mellor

Noel, It's been an absolute delight to know you as part of the community. As has been echoed above you're the greatest 4 large player there has ever been and the 925 numbers solve in your semi final will always remain an iconic moment. I have very fond memories of being soundly beaten in 4 large rou...

Elliott Mellor

James Robinson wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 24, 2018 11:03 pm

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 23, 2018 10:02 pm
What with Rhys wondering about Annie, I'm wondering if Jeff Clayton was invited?
He wasn't, I was so shocked that he didn't even get an invite, especially as there's only one from S76.

If that's the only basis you have for his case, I'm not surprised he wasn't invited at all.

Elliott Mellor

My simulations indicate that the estimates of the number of impossible answers are: no big numbers: 16.97% one big number : 2.73% two big numbers: 1.92% three big numbers: 5.35% four big numbers: 10.19% Do these estimates look reasonable? If I want a solution then I would pick two big numbers. Not ...

Elliott Mellor

Rhys Benjamin wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 22, 2018 8:23 am
Whilst I actually remember (and can't quite believe it hasn't come up) - Annie Humphries, was she invited?

I think she was invited but declined.

Elliott Mellor

Had a brief dream last night that Eddy Byrne had the world record for the longest marriage, at 95 years and was still going. Or sommat like that.

Elliott Mellor

Essentially the question was, what if what's shown on TV isn't the same as what happens in the studio. C1 and C2 are level going into the conundrum. Nobody gets it. They're given a tiebreak, and C1 gets it. The first conundrum is cut out for some reason. Does it count as a tiebreak? I think this is...

Elliott Mellor

Q: in event of a TB which is cut from broadcast (such as my first show), will this go down as a margin of 10 or a TB? Here’s how it will work: … In the event of a tie-break conundrum, this will be taken to be a 0 point win. ... Best of luck! I don't think that answers the question as well as you th...

Elliott Mellor

Rhys Benjamin wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 15, 2018 4:53 pm
Q: in event of a TB which is cut from broadcast (such as my first show), will this go down as a margin of 10 or a TB?

Zarte Siempre wrote: ↑
Wed Aug 29, 2018 11:13 am

Here’s how it will work:
…

In the event of a tie-break conundrum, this will be taken to be a 0 point win.

...

Best of luck!

Elliott Mellor

NASTALIQ!!!! <3

Elliott Mellor

Very detailed one last night...in this dream, I'm actually in champion of champions and it's implied I've won a series. My first match is against Spike, and I somehow beat him about 120ish to 50ish (heavily unrealistic!). The first rounds starts with Spike declaring 7 to my 8 and it turns out he had...

Elliott Mellor

"Just an 8"

Elliott Mellor

"Divine inspiration...or all your own work?"

Elliott Mellor

Rhys Benjamin wrote: ↑
Fri Aug 24, 2018 7:06 pm
I dreamt that Dylan Taylor was the Tory candidate in my constituency at the next general election. What happened next is not appropriate for this board.

The Tories got elected?

Elliott Mellor

(7+7)*8*8+25+5 for another 926 alt.

Elliott Mellor

Gavin Chipper: Elliott Mellor: I am using the incoherency solver and it often gives more than one solution. My original question was whether the solution set is complete. If incoherency gives only one answer then my question is not a meaningful question in the first place. Mathematics is never cons...

Elliott Mellor

I've just checked and it actually seems you are now right, it does give more than one solution. However I am certain this never used to be the case. It seems the solution set is complete - I just typed in a set of numbers and target that should give loads of solutions and indeed it gave me a heck of...

Elliott Mellor

Gavin Chipper: Thanks for the pointer to the "can of worms". I do not wish to re-open this "can of worms" but the equivalence problem is not exactly "rocket science"; any competent mathematician should be able to solve the problem. Maybe they could, but then another mathematician could solve the pr...

Elliott Mellor

Elliott Mellor: "More than 1. It will only ever give 1 solution regardless of whether there is 2 solutions or 200 solutions." I do not understand your statement. I have seen up to six alternative solutions from the incoherency solver. I've never really cared that much about it, but from any times I...

Elliott Mellor

Ryan Lam wrote: ↑
Wed Aug 22, 2018 4:18 am

Alternative to R6: ((25 x 2) + 6) x 10 + (4 x 3)

This was the way my mum did it, she promptly felt very proud of herself for getting one right

Elliott Mellor

Gavin Chipper: Thanks for the pointer to the "can of worms". I do not wish to re-open this "can of worms" but the equivalence problem is not exactly "rocket science"; any competent mathematician should be able to solve the problem. Going back to the incoherency solver, suppose that there are "too m...

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll: Why are you so certain that the incoherency solver gives all possible solutions to a given problem? I presume that you have not analysed each and every problem. Of course he hasn't analysed every single problem - he hasn't the time and nor has anyone. I can safely say that the numbers...

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Tue Aug 14, 2018 6:51 pm

Elliott Mellor wrote: ↑
Tue Aug 14, 2018 6:16 pm
After the conundrum went unsolved, Nick rolled it right away. I've often wondered why this sometimes happens - is it because someone in the audience guessed it wrong or some other reason?
Maybe sometimes they can forget?

Could be, just wondered if there was something more.

Elliott Mellor

After the conundrum went unsolved, Nick rolled it right away. I've often wondered why this sometimes happens - is it because someone in the audience guessed it wrong or some other reason?

Elliott Mellor

The only one reservation is that the uptake could well be ridiculously large. If it's open to any and all televised contestants you could well end up at a figure approaching 4,000. Really doubt it'd be even close to that tbh. Most one time winners who were on 12 years ago aren't going to be interes...

Elliott Mellor

Cannot help but feel the challenger was very similar to James Kennedy

Elliott Mellor

Why particularly if you like football? In your Facebook discussion, I think it was worded as if it was exclusively for people who liked football, so I feel I'm at least allowed to comment here. But I think most of what I'm about to say has been covered on Facebook. Basically, people like the sport(...

Elliott Mellor

Extending on that, I can see Bob posing at least a bit of a threat in the finals, though his conundrums are definitely a weakness.

Elliott Mellor

HOMELAND was a fabulous spot today by Bob, beat me completely there.

Elliott Mellor

Because all of my devices are Windows, and Windows and Apple don't always play together so well when you try to make them talk (At least, they don't when I try and make them - it's probably easy for someone who's less technophobic). Additionally I already have a "serious" laptop for my job, so if I...

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Sun Jul 29, 2018 6:21 pm
How come you wanna sell it Zarte?

You could try reading the post, you know.

Elliott Mellor

Accidentally quoted instead of edited. Deleted.

Elliott Mellor

Very weird one last night...Jeff Clayton had been allowed back on Countdown and was filming his 8th game in his run (his points total was something around 690 so far I believe, I have a feeling it was 694). He was facing some really old geezer who seemed to either win the round or offer an invalid w...

Elliott Mellor

Think Bob is the best bet we've seen for octochampdom so far I think. He has a good wordbank for a non-apterite and his numbers are solid enough. Nevertheless, despite the difference in maxes, Alex put up a good fight and left with a decent losing score. Though , Bob's mannerisms make him remind me...

Elliott Mellor

Well done to Ryan, but he didn't half spend ages declaring (gave the impression he was looking for something longer to declare eg sssssssssssssssssss could have turned into sssssssssssseven has he spotted one).

Elliott Mellor

The basic rule is that single-syllable adjectives can have ER and EST added by default, whereas with adjectives that have two or more syllables, the comparatives and superlatives have to be explicitly specified. If a cheese is more goaty, then you can call it "more goaty". GOATIER might seem logica...

Elliott Mellor

It'd be interesting to see the verdict of the actual producer on this. I'm happy to concede if wrong but there are certain rules that they apply eg the restaurant rule. If a cheese is more goaty than the other than how do you describe it? GOATIER, GOATIEST seem logical. The basic rule is that singl...

Elliott Mellor

Sarah Millican tried goatier once on Cats Countdown - disallowed When? Don't know. Some time back. U could find it on All4 Then it holds no water. Dictionary updates happen all the time and many words disallowed previously are now valid. The only way to know for sure if it would be allowed is to as...

Elliott Mellor

Steve Hawdon wrote: ↑
Sat Jul 21, 2018 4:51 pm
Sarah Millican tried goatier once on Cats Countdown - disallowed

When?

Elliott Mellor

Fred Mumford wrote: ↑
Sat Jul 21, 2018 4:26 pm

Elliott Mellor wrote: ↑
Sat Jul 21, 2018 3:41 pm
If a cheese can have a goaty flavour, how do you refer to a cheese that is a bit more so?
Repulsive?

*Likes comment*

Elliott Mellor

It'd be interesting to see the verdict of the actual producer on this. I'm happy to concede if wrong but there are certain rules that they apply eg the restaurant rule. If a cheese is more goaty than the other than how do you describe it? GOATIER, GOATIEST seem logical.

Elliott Mellor

Sorry. Comparative adjective needs to be specified in the OED to be valid. It is not. Therefore invalid It's not specified in the free online dictionary, but it might be in the paid-for version. It's valid on Apterous so it probably is. I'm surprised you can't tell from what I've written that I've ...

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Thu Jul 19, 2018 3:06 pm
They don't usually have a presentation for the winner of the coc like they do for regular series do they?

They do, actually. Glitter falls from the ceiling and the winner gets a new car, £50000 and a lot of pride. It used to be £100000 but budget cuts reduced this.

Elliott Mellor

Christy Cooper wrote: ↑
Mon Jul 16, 2018 7:41 pm
Jonathan Wynn is a good player too, I'd definitely place him near the top.

With all due respect to him I'm not sure I'd agree with him being amongst the very top. I don't think he would either in fairness. Top guy though.

Elliott Mellor

I also bought the latest dictionary today. Well, that you can buy. That should help me get better at countdown! It's the 2012 edition. They said in the bookshop that that's the most up to date version that you can buy! I'm hoping that the online version won't be too much different. Although I could...

Elliott Mellor

And if you're the second tallest then who's the tallest? Richard Osman is. It's a little known fact that Richard Osman was on countdown and made the final, losing narrowly to a guy called Harry Peters. However this was never broadcast due to some controversy sadly. The guy on pointless? Yes

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Sat Jul 14, 2018 4:57 pm
And if you're the second tallest then who's the tallest?

Richard Osman is. It's a little known fact that Richard Osman was on countdown and made the final, losing narrowly to a guy called Harry Peters. However this was never broadcast due to some controversy sadly.

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Sat Jul 14, 2018 2:04 am

Mark James wrote: ↑
Sat Jul 14, 2018 1:09 am

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Fri Jul 13, 2018 11:14 pm
What are we supposed to do here?
Watch for death.
No seriously. Please explain the whole thing

1) Watch to see if anyone notable has died.
2) Feel sad/happy/indifferent
3) Report here who has died.
4) If you predicted said person would die, you gain some points.

There you go.

Elliott Mellor

Zarte Siempre wrote: ↑
Wed Jul 11, 2018 1:43 pm
I know it was "only" a 6, but I genuinely think POIPOI might be one of the best spots I've ever seen...

This. There's nothing in that selection that even hints at a 6 being there - magnificent spot.

Elliott Mellor

d) ...that maybe they're just there to have fun? Fine we may nearly all be dedicated weirdos who want to better our play on a constant basis until we've learnt every word in the dictionary, but for so many people just sitting in the chair once is for an adrenalin buzz, or to knock something off of ...

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Fri Jul 06, 2018 7:38 pm
Again, not the place to post it but if I get onto the show, unless I'm coming across one of your family or friends or people who've been on this site longer than me, can I please ask you's to root for me?

Elliott Mellor

Think Lewis could become an octochamp? I don't think he will, personally, but he seems nice. His average is just below 90 a game, so yeah if he does he won't be one of the best octochamps we've seen. Impossible to really say tbh - we've had contestants better than him who've met their match and los...

Elliott Mellor

Zarte Siempre wrote: ↑
Tue Jul 03, 2018 9:35 am
Dour weddings and a funeral

Pretty much sums up most of the soaps that are on TV.

Elliott Mellor

Owen Carroll wrote: ↑
Mon Jul 02, 2018 7:16 pm
Bad luck Jodine. But I thought that might happen. Well done Lewis. Innis are you two related?

I think you can all guess why I hate that conundrum

Are you related to Lewis Carroll? What about Pete Carroll? Pat Carroll?

Elliott Mellor

Adam Dexter wrote: ↑
Mon Jul 02, 2018 5:30 pm
URINES mass noun... what about the Restaurant Rule?

Not many people order urine at a restaurant, it seems.

Elliott Mellor

As Elliot Mellor has pointed out, my values were gross over estimates. The correct results appear to be for 6 small, 0 large = 2850 for 5 small, 1 large = 1452*4 = 5808 for 4 small, 2 large = 615*6 = 3690 for 3 small, 3 large = 210*4 = 840 for 2 small, 4 large = 55*1 = 55 total = 13243 This number ...

Elliott Mellor

A small sample fraction of then solvable and unsolvable problems can be used to study the number problem. It is possible to do (Monte Carlo) simulations without storing much data but the program which classifies the solvable and non-solvable problems has to be 100% accurate. Web based programs are ...

Elliott Mellor

Thanks for links for solvers. I am interested in analysing (a) impossible problems (b) problems which are solvable but declared as impossible initially (c) problems with unconventional solutions There's such a large volume of numbers games (around 12 million it seems) that could happen that unless ...

Search found 510 matches